Types of Valve Replacement

Broadly speaking, there are two types of valve replacement. Both have got their pros and cons, and your surgeon will explain these to you. 

Mechanical Valve

A mechanical valve is made of durable materials like carbon and will last a long time. However, patients who receive a mechanical valve need to take blood-thinning medications (anticoagulants) for the rest of their lives to prevent blood clots from forming on the valve. Blood clots may lead to a stroke.

Biological (Tissue) Valve

A biological valve is made from animal tissue (often from a pig or cow). Biological valves do not require long-term anticoagulant therapy, but they will not last as long as mechanical valves.

The decision between a mechanical or tissue heart valve is an important one and should be made in consultation with your healthcare provider. There are several factors to consider when deciding between these two types of heart valves:

  1. Age and Life Expectancy: Mechanical valves are more durable and will last a lifetime, while tissue valves have a limited lifespan (usually around 10-20 years). Younger patients (<50 years old) may need to undergo multiple surgeries if they choose tissue valves so usually have mechanical valves implanted. Older patients (>70 years old) will have the complications associated with anticoagulation (which are more common in older patients) so usually have tissue valves implanted.

 

  1. Medical History and Health: Your overall health, existing medical conditions, and any medications you're taking can impact the suitability of each type of valve. Patients with certain medical conditions may be better suited for one type over the other.

 

  1. Anticoagulation Therapy: Mechanical valves are prone to forming blood clots, so patients with mechanical valves require lifelong anticoagulation (blood thinners) with warfarin to prevent clots. Warfarin needs regular monitoring to ensure the correct dosage. Warfarin increases the risk of bleeding, and this risk is higher in older patients (>70 years old). Tissue valves do not usually require long-term anticoagulation, which may be a factor to consider. Sometimes anticoagulation for 3 months is recommended for tissue valves.



  2. Activity Level and Lifestyle: Patients with mechanical valves must be cautious with activities that could cause bleeding or injury due to the anticoagulation therapy. Tissue valve recipients might have fewer activity restrictions.

 

  1. Surgical Risk The initial surgery to implant a mechanical or tissue valve carries risks. Additionally, if a tissue valve wears out, a second surgery is required for replacement. The risks and recovery associated with this second surgery should be considered.

 

  1. Personal Preference: Some patients have strong preferences based on factors like their comfort with taking lifelong medication, their willingness to undergo multiple surgeries, and their understanding of the associated risks.

 

  1. Follow-up Care: Mechanical valve recipients need regular monitoring of blood clotting levels (INR) and adjustments to their anticoagulation therapy. However, this can often be done at home with the purchase of a home INR monitoring kit. Tissue valve recipients need long-term follow-up with annual transthoracic echo scans to monitor the valve's function and lifespan.

 

  1. Patient's Anatomy: The patient's anatomy and specific heart condition might influence which type of valve is more suitable.

 

  1. Pregnancy – for females of childbearing age, careful consideration needs to be given for the choice of valve substitute. Warfarin use (for mechanical valves) is teratogenic for foetuses during pregnancy with the greatest risk in the first trimester.  Pregnancy in patients with mechanical valves needs careful management in conjunction with a haematologist and cardiologist. Depending on the dose of warfarin, you may have to transition on to low molecular weight heparin injections for a while, which is associated with a higher risk of blood clot formation on the mechanical valve compared to warfarin.  Many female patients opt for tissue valves during the years when they are planning their family, and then have the valve changed when it degenerates.

 

Ultimately, the decision should be a collaborative one between you and your surgeon. Your medical team will consider your individual health status, lifestyle, preferences, and the potential risks and benefits of each type of valve. It's important to have thorough discussions and seek second opinions if necessary before making this significant decision.

Leading Surgeon for Keyhole & Robotic Heart Surgery

Mr. Paul Modi, Top Heart Surgeon in London.

Meet Mr Paul Modi, the foremost robotic heart surgeon in the United Kingdom and Director of the Keyhole and Robotic Heart Surgery Centre. With a distinguished career in heart surgery spanning 25 years, he has consistently pushed the boundaries of medical science and surgical excellence. Recognized globally for his pioneering work in robotic-assisted heart procedures, patients from across the UK and internationally seek the expertise of this visionary surgeon. He has an unwavering commitment to innovation and safety, coupled with a compassionate patient-centered approach. Read what patients have to say about him here. 

Mr Modi was trained in the US, UK, and Europe not just by one of the pioneers of robotic and keyhole heart surgery, but by all six of them. No other surgeon in the UK (or the world) has achieved this breadth of training and he has brought all this knowledge he learned overseas back to the NHS. He has the largest practice of robotic and keyhole heart surgery in the UK and is a national and international trainer in many of these techniques.  Many of his colleagues consider him as the best heart surgeon for keyhole mitral valve surgery in the UK.

When it comes to matters of the heart for either yourself or a loved one, we invite you to contact us today and schedule a consultation. 

Trained in the US and Germany by all the original masters of keyhole and robotic heart surgery.

No other UK surgeon has been trained by all these masters.

a. Dr Ranny Chitwood in North Carolina who did the original FDA trial for the use of the Da Vinci robot in heart surgery
b. Dr Doug Murphy in Atlanta who has performed more robotic surgeries than anybody else in the world
c. Dr Sam Balkhy in Chicago who is widely regarded as the best robotic coronary surgeon in the world
d. Prof Fred Mohr in Germany, a master surgeon, and inventor of the GoreTex loop technique we use for mitral valve repair
e. Dr Hugo Vanermen in Belgium who taught us all so much about the benefits of totally endoscopic surgery

On the shoulders of giants we stand.

Top Doctors Verified Reviews

  • D. P. - Verified Patient
    Following my referral to Mr. Modi, my treatment has been exemplary. The care following my mitral valve repair by minimally invasive surgery was outstanding.
    D. P. - Verified Patient
  • L. D. - Verified Patient
    Not enough space to do justice to Mr Modi, his team and the nursing staff at LHCH. Quite simply superb and I am so grateful for Mr Modi's skill and attention.
    L. D. - Verified Patient
  • P. D. - Verified Patient
    The Phone call was a very effective way of providing me with information going forward and I appreciate Paul's time in contacting me. Excellent all round.
    P. D. - Verified Patient
  • S. P. - Verified Patient
    Highly recommended. Dr Modi performed a mitral valve repair (combined mini invasive/robotic). I was fully informed, always in contact. Lucky me !
    S. P. - Verified Patient
  • S. - Verified Patient
    Excellent discussion about surgery, thorough consent process emphasising safety as paramount. Great team, kind, professional & I felt reassured. Perfect outcome.
    S. - Verified Patient
  • O. - Verified Patient
    To put it simply, Mr=Modi is one in his own class. If you need a heart surgery, don’t look any further. We came from London, and never regretted.
    O. - Verified Patient
  • V. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi is an artist in what he does. And his care for patients is second to none, far beyond the call of duty. Staff at LHCH are incredibly kind and patient.
    V. - Verified Patient
  • J. M. - Verified Patient
    A professional gentleman.He has a calm assuring honest manner.Unhurried.Clear concise realistic advice on options and outcomes.I feel safe being in his care.
    J. M. - Verified Patient
  • J. G. - Verified Patient
    Everything about this procedure was first class and beyond criticism. My quick, problem free, recovery proved it. I highly recommend Mr P Modi in all aspects.
    J. G. - Verified Patient
  • M. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi is all that a patient could wish for in a heart consultant..expert, accessible, down-to-earth', reassuring, and leader of a responsive team.Excellent.
    M. - Verified Patient
  • A. L. - Verified Patient
    Wait in part caused by infection caught in UHW Cardiff & by Intraclude problems. Suggest they bring back phlebotomists to LHCH.
    A. L. - Verified Patient
  • B. C. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi and his team were superb. He personally sat down and explained everything pre-op. He would visit me daily post-op and addressed any concerns. I'm making a good recovery and he's been supportive even during this period. He listens to you.Top Doc.
    B. C. - Verified Patient
  • P. - Verified Patient
    I have nothing but praise for Paul's explanation and delivery of what is a very traumatic and worrying operation. Paul's bedside manner is exceptional, always making time to explain in detail any questions or concerns. I felt 100% safe in Paul's care.
    P. - Verified Patient
  • M. M. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi is a kind, thoughtful surgeon who immediately put me at ease in spite of how daunting my condition felt. He explains things clearly and talks to, not at. Anyone who has him as their surgeon is in good hands with the best possible care.
    M. M. - Verified Patient
  • M. M. - Verified Patient
    Mentally coping with the daunting prospect of a triple bypass off pump operation I thought be a serious challenge. However Mr Paul Modi and his team made the whole experience easy to cope with under the circumstances. Back home 2 hrs away 4 days later.
    M. M. - Verified Patient
  • J. H. - Verified Patient
    I feel very privileged that Mr. Modi was my surgeon – he is very much a talented, accomplished and skilled specialist. I could not fault his patience, kindness and sincerity whilst preparing me for my open-heart surgery which was very much maintained during my follow-up clinic meeting. In addition to his operating abilities, he put me totally at my ease and offered reassurance during the most anxious time in my life. The ‘before and after care’ is very important to patients. I am fortunate that I was the recipient of his competence and expertise.
    J. H. - Verified Patient
  • S. - Verified Patient
    My experience with Mr Modi can only be describe as exceptional and excellent. In my 10 days as an in-patient I regularly saw Mr Modi and he personally kept me informed and updated with all developments of my care and treatment. I would highly recommend.
    S. - Verified Patient
  • B. W. - Verified Patient
    I highly recommend Mr. Modi, I am extremely grateful for the skill, care and attention provided by Mr. Modi and all of his team.
    B. W. - Verified Patient
  • P. H. - Verified Patient
    I was extremely impressed with Mr Modi in every interaction I had. He always came across as extremely knowledgeable and capable and made me feel that my questions and views mattered in the consultation. I would certainly recommend Mr Modi.
    P. H. - Verified Patient
  • P. G. - Verified Patient
    Mr Paul Modi is at the top of his field regarding Robotic Mitral Valve surgery and I was privileged to be one of his patients in the last year.
    P. G. - Verified Patient
  • J. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi always at pains to clearly explain the procedures that i would undergo as a patient and gave me an excellent base for my expectations as to what would happen during the surgical procedures & Post operation , a truly Excellent DR.
    J. - Verified Patient
  • J. B. - Verified Patient
    I have great confidence in Mr Modi's professional abilities and Patient care
    J. B. - Verified Patient
  • S. B. - Verified Patient
    Mr Paul Modi and his team provide a very positive patient based experience. Mr Modi knowledge and experience was very apparent in the way he delivered very clear & detailed advise. He makes the patient feel comfortable and relaxed.
    S. B. - Verified Patient
  • M. K. - Verified Patient
    Paul Modi is outstanding. His incredible skill and expertise not to mention his calm manner provide massive reassurance. My Mitral Valve repair was a huge success and I now have my life back. Quite simply, he is the best there is.
    M. K. - Verified Patient
  • R. A. - Verified Patient
    Paul and his team performed a robot assisted heart bypass for me, I was leaving hospital on the third day and feeling much better again after just eight days, amazing
    R. A. - Verified Patient
  • A. S. - Verified Patient
    I had MV prolapse with severe regurgitation and Afib. Mr. Modi operated using minimally invasive technique. I was back on my feet within a week and travelled back to Pakistan a month later. Echo 3 months post surg. showed no regurg. Thank you Mr. Modi.
    A. S. - Verified Patient
  • S. G. - Verified Patient
    Ive just come through one of the most worrying time in my life. To say i was worried was an understatement. Paul was the only part of the process that i honestly didn't worry about, as I knew i had the best surgeon i could get. Totally recommended.
    S. G. - Verified Patient
  • J. W. - Verified Patient
    Paul successfully delivered everything he determined I required from complex heart surgery and he minimises risk through his approach.He delivered a MV repair, a t valve repair, Cox maze 4 and asd closure.Your in the best hands with paul, a great man.
    J. W. - Verified Patient
  • N. V. - Verified Patient
    I cannot fault Mr Modis professionalism he took a lot of time explaining the procedure and what was involved to me. I was under no illusion as to what would happen to me on the operating table. His post operative reassurance was also very welcoming.
    N. V. - Verified Patient
  • C. N. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi was recommended to me following two failed PCI attempts to a right coronary CTO . He was an extremely knowledgeable and thoroughly experienced surgeon who answered all my questions and concerns with patience and concern which inspired confidence.
    C. N. - Verified Patient
  • M. - Verified Patient
    I was referred to Mr. Modi after the diagnosis of triple vessel disease. He explained us the procedure and answered all our questions and concerns with professionalism. I highly recommend Mr. Modi and all of his team for their skill, care, and attention.
    M. - Verified Patient
  • M. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi has the ability to be professional,personable and reassuring.His manner is open and friendly.My many fears were discussed and allayed with ease.I wish I had met him much sooner.He has given me my spark for life again..Thank you.
    M. - Verified Patient
  • J. A. - Verified Patient
    Excellent consultation. I would not hesitate to recommend or use again.
    J. A. - Verified Patient
  • L. G. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi provided highly informed, expert and reassuring guidance throughout the run-in to mini-mitral surgery. The procedure itself was genuinely minimal in terms of scarring and recuperation, and Mr Modi continues to provide superb post-operative care.
    L. G. - Verified Patient
  • C. M. - Verified Patient
    He’s in the job for all the right reasons, number 1 being giving peoples lives back. He explains everything thoroughly before and after surgery. Positive results post surgery were felt as soon as coming round in POCCU and have continued at an amazing rate
    C. M. - Verified Patient
  • D. G. - Verified Patient
    I had approached Mr. Modi for a mitral valve repair. From the outset I found him to be professional, friendly and very approachable. He explained everything that would happen and was very reassuring. I knew I was I safe hands and the op was a success!
    D. G. - Verified Patient
  • J. D. - Verified Patient
    It is rare to encounter a Doctor/ Surgeon who is capable of demonstrating a combination of exceptional surgical skill and warm humanity. Mr Modi delivers both. He is a in a class of his own .
    J. D. - Verified Patient
  • E. L. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi is one of the most professional, kind, considerate, compassionate clinicians I have had the good fortune to meet. His surgical skills and care are without parallel. My recovery from minimally invasive mitral valve surgery has been amazing. Thanks!
    E. L. - Verified Patient
  • D. A. - Verified Patient
    I would give Mr Modi 5 stars for both his professionalism and approachability. He works tirelessly both during the procedure and after. Now home 5 days post op and experienced no pain whatsoever thank you Mr Modi
    D. A. - Verified Patient
  • D. - Verified Patient
    What a lovely caring man a doctor who puts you at your ease with a great sense of houmour I can not sing his praises enough total professional
    D. - Verified Patient
  • J. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi is reassuring in his manner and highly professional. Awaiting major heart surgery I felt incredibly calm as the whole procedure was fully explained by Mr Modi and I felt I was in very capable hands. He has given me my life back : thank you Paul
    J. - Verified Patient
  • D. M. - Verified Patient
    As a retired GP, my Cardiologist referred me from Yorkshire to the care of Mr Modi in Liverpool for surgery. I have seen many hospital systems in my career and can only describe the care I received under Mr Modi in Liverpool as "Outstanding". Thank you.
    D. M. - Verified Patient
  • A. N. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi was outstanding as was his team ,CCU were also outstanding and very caring ,as was the night and day nursing team .No complaints in any of my care just praise that my problem was sorted out.However only problem was with the office team ,and wait
    A. N. - Verified Patient
  • C. - Verified Patient
    I recently had minimal mitral heart repair & SAM procedure performed by Paul Modi. From initial consultation, surgery & post operative care - Paul is incredibly skilled, professional, considerate & informative. I would strongly recommend Paul & his team.
    C. - Verified Patient
  • R. - Verified Patient
    Would highly recommend. Mr Modi is clear, concise, reassuring and helped with future options.
    R. - Verified Patient
  • M. C. - Verified Patient
    Admitted for an unexpected heart by pass I was shocked and bewildered. Mr Modi was very reassuring from the outset. I quickly felt safe in his hands and soon knew what to expect. Mr Modi combines professionalism with warmth. My after care was excellent.
    M. C. - Verified Patient
  • I. H. - Verified Patient
    The whole experience of consultation, through surgical procedure, followed by subsequent care was first class. I have full confidence in Paul Modi and would have no hesitation in recommending him to a potential patient.
    I. H. - Verified Patient
  • J. - Verified Patient
    My experience of working with Mr Modi has been Outstanding. I would describe him as a “Gentleman Genius”. He has a down to earth attitude so I had no problem trusting in him. Before and after care was excellent and nothing was too much trouble for him.
    J. - Verified Patient
  • J. - Verified Patient
    I would recommend Mr Modi to anyone who has heart problems,from the moment I was appointed to him he explained everything to me in such detail I come away thinking that I new everything about my my condition and what was needed to put me back on the road
    J. - Verified Patient
  • M. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi throughout my operational period was a regular visitor to my bedside keeping me updated on every aspect of my post operation recovery. He offered a great insight about the actual procedure and time scales on recovery and appointments going forward
    M. - Verified Patient
  • J. B. - Verified Patient
    Mr Modi came highly recommended as the best by my cardiologist when I found out I required heart surgery. He certainly is. At all times I was reassured, put at ease and both my family and I felt I was in very safe hands.
    J. B. - Verified Patient
  • V. - Verified Patient
    I feel extremely fortunate to have been in the care of Mr Modi & his excellent team. My condition was poor prior to surgery making it a particularly difficult procedure which he helped me through both physically and mentally.
    V. - Verified Patient
  • P. - Verified Patient
    From my first meeting with Mr Modi I was put at ease by his calm and confident manner. All of my options were explained to me. The operation went smoothly and I am now well on my way to full recovery.
    P. - Verified Patient
  • P. M. - Verified Patient
    Experienced but innovative, Paul explained options, risks and outcomes clearly. The heart bypass was "excellent outcome" and I was home in 6 days. No pain since leaving hospital, wound healed quickly and cleanly. After care great and efficient. A kind man
    P. M. - Verified Patient
  • S. C. - Verified Patient
    Great care and a very good communicator. Honest presentation of all the options available for treatment, the advantages , likely outcomes and risks attached to the surgery. Absolutely happy to have "my life in his hands!"
    S. C. - Verified Patient
  • C. - Verified Patient
    Excellent does not even begin to describe this surgeon. His surgical ability, care & attention are exemplary. He is very approachable & kind.I am very grateful that he carried out my surgery.
    C. - Verified Patient