Types of Valve Replacement
Broadly speaking, there are two types of valve replacement. Both have got their pros and cons, and your surgeon will explain these to you.
Mechanical Valve
A mechanical valve is made of durable materials like carbon and will last a long time. However, patients who receive a mechanical valve need to take blood-thinning medications (anticoagulants) for the rest of their lives to prevent blood clots from forming on the valve. Blood clots may lead to a stroke.

Biological (Tissue) Valve
A biological valve is made from animal tissue (often from a pig or cow). Biological valves do not require long-term anticoagulant therapy, but they will not last as long as mechanical valves.

The decision between a mechanical or tissue heart valve is an important one and should be made in consultation with your healthcare provider. There are several factors to consider when deciding between these two types of heart valves:
- Age and Life Expectancy: Mechanical valves are more durable and will last a lifetime, while tissue valves have a limited lifespan (usually around 10-20 years). Younger patients (<50 years old) may need to undergo multiple surgeries if they choose tissue valves so usually have mechanical valves implanted. Older patients (>70 years old) will have the complications associated with anticoagulation (which are more common in older patients) so usually have tissue valves implanted.
- Medical History and Health: Your overall health, existing medical conditions, and any medications you're taking can impact the suitability of each type of valve. Patients with certain medical conditions may be better suited for one type over the other.
- Anticoagulation Therapy: Mechanical valves are prone to forming blood clots, so patients with mechanical valves require lifelong anticoagulation (blood thinners) with warfarin to prevent clots. Warfarin needs regular monitoring to ensure the correct dosage. Warfarin increases the risk of bleeding, and this risk is higher in older patients (>70 years old). Tissue valves do not usually require long-term anticoagulation, which may be a factor to consider. Sometimes anticoagulation for 3 months is recommended for tissue valves.

- Activity Level and Lifestyle: Patients with mechanical valves must be cautious with activities that could cause bleeding or injury due to the anticoagulation therapy. Tissue valve recipients might have fewer activity restrictions.
- Surgical Risk The initial surgery to implant a mechanical or tissue valve carries risks. Additionally, if a tissue valve wears out, a second surgery is required for replacement. The risks and recovery associated with this second surgery should be considered.
- Personal Preference: Some patients have strong preferences based on factors like their comfort with taking lifelong medication, their willingness to undergo multiple surgeries, and their understanding of the associated risks.
- Follow-up Care: Mechanical valve recipients need regular monitoring of blood clotting levels (INR) and adjustments to their anticoagulation therapy. However, this can often be done at home with the purchase of a home INR monitoring kit. Tissue valve recipients need long-term follow-up with annual transthoracic echo scans to monitor the valve's function and lifespan.
- Patient's Anatomy: The patient's anatomy and specific heart condition might influence which type of valve is more suitable.
- Pregnancy – for females of childbearing age, careful consideration needs to be given for the choice of valve substitute. Warfarin use (for mechanical valves) is teratogenic for foetuses during pregnancy with the greatest risk in the first trimester. Pregnancy in patients with mechanical valves needs careful management in conjunction with a haematologist and cardiologist. Depending on the dose of warfarin, you may have to transition on to low molecular weight heparin injections for a while, which is associated with a higher risk of blood clot formation on the mechanical valve compared to warfarin. Many female patients opt for tissue valves during the years when they are planning their family, and then have the valve changed when it degenerates.
Ultimately, the decision should be a collaborative one between you and your surgeon. Your medical team will consider your individual health status, lifestyle, preferences, and the potential risks and benefits of each type of valve. It's important to have thorough discussions and seek second opinions if necessary before making this significant decision.
Leading Surgeon for Keyhole & Robotic Heart Surgery
Mr. Paul Modi, Top Heart Surgeon in London.
Meet Mr Paul Modi, the foremost robotic heart surgeon in the United Kingdom and Director of the Keyhole and Robotic Heart Surgery Centre. With a distinguished career in heart surgery spanning 25 years, he has consistently pushed the boundaries of medical science and surgical excellence. Recognized globally for his pioneering work in robotic-assisted heart procedures, patients from across the UK and internationally seek the expertise of this visionary surgeon. He has an unwavering commitment to innovation and safety, coupled with a compassionate patient-centered approach. Read what patients have to say about him here.
Mr Modi was trained in the US, UK, and Europe not just by one of the pioneers of robotic and keyhole heart surgery, but by all six of them. No other surgeon in the UK (or the world) has achieved this breadth of training and he has brought all this knowledge he learned overseas back to the NHS. He has the largest practice of robotic and keyhole heart surgery in the UK and is a national and international trainer in many of these techniques. Many of his colleagues consider him as the best heart surgeon for keyhole mitral valve surgery in the UK.
When it comes to matters of the heart for either yourself or a loved one, we invite you to contact us today and schedule a consultation.

Trained in the US and Germany by all the original masters of keyhole and robotic heart surgery.
No other UK surgeon has been trained by all these masters.
a. Dr Ranny Chitwood in North Carolina who did the original FDA trial for the use of the Da Vinci robot in heart surgery
b. Dr Doug Murphy in Atlanta who has performed more robotic surgeries than anybody else in the world
c. Dr Sam Balkhy in Chicago who is widely regarded as the best robotic coronary surgeon in the world
d. Prof Fred Mohr in Germany, a master surgeon, and inventor of the GoreTex loop technique we use for mitral valve repair
e. Dr Hugo Vanermen in Belgium who taught us all so much about the benefits of totally endoscopic surgery
On the shoulders of giants we stand.



